Pages

Monday, July 27, 2015

CODE OF PRACTICE FOR MOTOR VEHICLE SALVAGE DISPOSAL (INDIA)

CODE OF PRACTICE FOR MOTOR VEHICLE SALVAGE DISPOSAL (INDIA)
CATEGORY
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
Type of Damages
Vehicle Engine Body shell, Chassis Badly damaged and beyond repairs. Total Burnt Vehicle Cases

Vehicle badly damaged and opined that same can by no means made fit to ply on roads again
Vehicle major damage, May require replacement of either engine or chassis and may get repaired
Vehicle major damage, settlement made considering new parts, but can be repaired  and made fit to ply on roads
Vehicle damage settled due to less IDV or being nil dep policy and vehicle can be repaired and  is still roadworthy
Vehicle theft cases
Accidental of Non Accidental, But completed the life and life not further extended 
Condition
Vehicle having become junk / scrap only
Most of vehicle will be junk/scrap but some parts will be re-useable as safe
REPAIRABLE Replacement with engine or chassis and old and new parts
REPAIRABLE Repairs instead of replacement of parts and use of old and new making viable the repairs
REPAIRABLE
Normal means of repairs
Vehicle not traceable
Not being further used as completed its useful life
Example
Total burnt, Complete vehicle crushed
Extensively damaged and can not be repaired
Requires veh. ID part replacement
Body shell damaged and can be repaired does not require veh ID parts replacement
Normal repairs
Entire vehicle stolen
Old vehicle and not being in use further
ROAD WORTHINESS
NEITHER E ROADWORHTY NOR REPAIRABLE
Disabled and may become roadworthy after repairs
REAPIRABLE AND WILL BE ROADWORTHY
NA
MAY OR MAYNOT BE ROADWORHTY
Type of settlement
Total Loss  Cases
Constructive Total cases

Total loss
Abandoned Vehicle
Registration  certificate status
R/C must be cancelled and as per provision of Sec 55 of MV Act The owner be advised to inform the RTO and get the R/C Cancelled.
Insurers to Request for suspension of R/C with RTO under Sec 53 of MV Act
No Action except for change of ownership if required
As in Case A type
R/C validity has expired
What should be done for Registration certificate
The VIN No. plate be removed and submitted with RTO. After cancellation of R/C the Chassis no and Engine numbers may be got destroyed and photo records be kept by the owner.
R/C  to be submitted with RTO & will remain suspended and buyer will either get suspension revoked under sec 53 of MV act or may get the R/C cancelled as per Sec 55 of MV act and follow mode as in Category A and B.
No action
R/C must be got cancelled

Public may be notified and R/C be kept in own possession in records
What should be done with security number plate
The Security Registration Number Plate should be damaged and submitted with RTO and photo records of same be kept.
The Number plates must be removed and submitted with the RTO during the suspended R/C period and buyer if opts for repairs then he on getting revoked the R/C can get the same from RTO issued or reissued
No Action
No Action can be taken
The same be removed and either kept in records or destroyed and record of same be kept
Sale value will be for
The Sale of wreck/ junk be made and valuation of same will be based on saleable vehicle by weight.
The sale will be based on the wreck value along with salvage value of re-useable parts
Salvage or wreck as per the buyers decision
Salvage in repairable condition
No Sale value . Only if recovered the same will be applicable as per condition on recovery as category A, B, C,D or E.
For junk of vehicle
Documentation with the buyer
Cancelled RC Copy be provided to buyer and Affidavit be obtained from buyer for dismantling the vehicle along with ID and Address proof of buyer
Letter for request for suspension of R/C be provided and RTO may after passing of fitness tests for roadworthiness and mode and means of repairs used scrutiny, allow R/C restoration and may charge applicable registration taxes
R/C and transfer papers be provided to buyer after getting full payments and clearance of hyp

If recovered sale will be as per category applicable
Only photocopy of R/C be provided to buyer with remarks sale for dismantling of vehicle on it
Registration taxes
Owner on cancellation of RC may apply for refund of lifetime tax  if applicable in his case.
Owner may apply for refund of lifetime tax if applicable in his case
The buyer if repairs and gets R/C revoked will have to pay the taxes for further periods opted as annual or life long
Owner may negotiate for same with the buyer
Owner on cancellation of RC may apply for refund of lifetime tax  if applicable in his case.
Not Applicable





i

The Section 53, 54 and Sec 55 of INDIAN MV Act 1988 are reproduced below

53.  Suspension  of  registration. – 

(1)  If  any  registering  authority  or  other  prescribed  authority  has  reason  to  believe  that  any  motor  vehicle  within  its  jurisdiction -  (a) is  in  such  a  condition  that  its  use  in  a  public  place  would  constitute  a  danger  to  the  public,  or  that  it  fails  to  comply  with  the  requirements  of  this  Act  or  of  the  rules  made  thereunder,  or   (b) has  been, o r  is  being,  used  for  hire  or  reward  without  a  valid  permit  for  being  used  as  such, the  authority  may,  after  giving  the  owner  an  opportunity  of  making  any  representation  he  may  wish  to  make  (by  sending  to  the  owner  a  notice  by  registered  post  acknowledgment  due  at  his  address  entered  in  the  certificate  of  registration),  for  reasons  to  be  recorded  in  writing,  suspend  the  certificate  of  registration  of  the  vehicle- (i) in  any  case  falling  under  clause (a),  until  the  defects  are rectified  to  its  satisfaction;  and (ii) in  any  case  falling  under  clause (b),  for  a period  not  exceeding  four  months. (2) an  authority  other  than  a  registering  authority  shall,  when  making  a  suspension  order  under  sub-section (1),  intimate  in  writing  the  fact  of  such  suspension  and  the  reasons  therefor  to  the  registering  authority  within  whose  jurisdiction  the  vehicle  is  at  the  time  of  the  suspension. (3) Where  the  registration  of  a  motor  vehicle  has  been  suspended  under  sub-section  (1)  for  a  continuous  period  of  not  less  than  one  month, the  registering  authority,  within  whose  jurisdiction  the  vehicle  was  when  the  registration  was  suspended,  shall,  if  it  is  not  the  original  registering  authority,  inform  that  authority  of  the  suspension.

(4) The  owner  of  a  motor  vehicle  shall,  on  the  demand  of  a  registering  authority  or  other  prescribed  authority  which  has  suspended  the  certificate  of  registration  of  the  vehicle  under  this  section,  surrender  the  certificate  of  registration. (5)   A  certificate  of  registration  surrendered  under  sub – section  (4)  shall  be  returned  to  the owner  when  the  order  suspending  registration  has  been  rescinded  and  not  before.
 Corresponding  Law. – Section 53  corresponds  to  section  33  of  the  Motor  Vehicles  Act, 1939.
Objects  and  Reasons. – Clause  54  empowers  the  registering  authorities  to    suspend  the  certificate  of  registration  of  a  motor  vehicle,  if  the  vehicle  is  used  for  hire  or  reward  without  a  permit.  It  also  empowers  the  registering  authority  to  suspend  the  certificate  of  registration  of  a  vehicle  if  the  vehicle  is  mechanically  defective  or  if  its  use  on  public  road  will  endanger  public  safety  until  the  defects  are  rectified  and  the  vehicle  is  certified  to  be  road  worthy.

54.  Cancellation  of  registration  suspended  under  section 
53. – 

Where  the  suspension  of  registration  of  a  vehicle  under  section  53  has  continued  without  interruption  for  a period  of  not  less  than  six  months,  the  registering  authority  within  whose  jurisdiction  the  vehicle  was  when  the  registration  was  suspended,  may,  if  it  is  the  original  registering  authority,  cancel  the  registration,  and if  it  is  not  the  original  registering  authority,  shall  forward  the  certificate  of  registration  to  that  authority  which  may  cancel  the  registration.
Corresponding  Law. – This  is  a  new  provision  in  the  1988  Act.


55. Cancellation  of  registration. – 

(1)  If  a  motor  vehicle  has  been  destroyed  or  has  been  rendered  permanently  incapable  of  use,  the  owner  shall,  within  fourteen  days  or  as  soon  as  may  be,  report  the  fact  to  the  registering  authority  within  whose  jurisdiction  he  has  the  residence or  place  of  business 

where  the  vehicle  is  normally  kept,  as  the  case  may  be,  and  shall  forward  to  the  authority  the  certificate  of  registration  of  the  vehicle. (2) The  registering  authority  shall,  if  it  is  the  original  registering  authority,  cancel  the  registration  and  the  certificate  of  registration,  or,  if  it  is  not,  shall  forward  the  report  and  the  certificate  of  registration  to  the  original  registering  authority  and  that  authority  shall  cancel  the  registration. (3) Any  registering  authority  may  order  the  examination  of  a motor  vehicle  within  its  jurisdiction  by  such  authority  as  the  State Government  may  by  order  appoint  and,  if  upon  such  examination  and after  giving  the  owner  an  opportunity  to  make  any  representation  he  may  wish  to  make  (by  sending  to  the  owner  a  notice  by  registered  post  acknowledgement  due  at  his  address  entered  in  the  certificate  of  registration),  it  is  satisfied  that  the  vehicle  is  in  such  a  condition  that  it  is  incapable  of   being  used  or its  use  in  a public  place  would  constitute  a  danger  to  the  public  and  that  it  is  beyond  reasonable  repair,  may  cancel  the  registration. (4) If  a  registering  authority  is  satisfied  that  a  motor  vehicle  has  been  permanently  removed  out  of  India,  the  registering  authority  shall  cancel  the  registration. (5) If  a  registering  authority  is  satisfied  that  the  registration  of  a motor  vehicle  has  been  obtained  on  the  basis  of  documents  which  were,  or  by  representation  of  facts  which  was,  false  in  any  material  particular,  or  the  engine  number  or  the  chassis  number  embossed  thereon  are  different  from  such  number  entered  in  the  certificate  of  registration,  the  registering  authority  shall  after  giving  the  owner  an  opportunity  to  make  such  representation  as  he  may  wish  to  make  (by  sending  to  the  owner  a  notice  by  registered  post  acknowledgement  due  at  his  address  entered  in  the  certificate  of  registration),  and  for  reasons  to  be  recorded  in  writing,  cancel  the  registration. (6) A  registering  authority  cancelling  the  registration  of  a  motor  vehicle  under  section  54  or  under  this  section  shall  communicate  such  fact  in 
 
writing  to  the  owner  of  the  vehicle,  and  the  owner  of  the  vehicle  shall  forthwith  surrender  to  that  authority  the  certificate  of  registration o f  the vehicle. (7) A  registering  authority  making  an  order  of  cancellation  under  section  54  or  under  this  section  shall,  if  it  is  the  original  registering  authority,  cancel  the  certificate  of  registration  and  the  entry  relating  to  the  vehicle  in  its  records,  and,  if  it  is  not  the  original  registering  authority,  forward  the  certificate  of  registration  to  that  authority,  and  that  authority  shall  cancel  the  certificate  of  registration  and  the  entry  relating  to  the  motor  vehicle  in  its  records. (8) The  expression “original  registering  authority”  in  this  section  and  in  section  41,49,50,51,52,53  and  54  means  the  registering  authority  in  whose  records  the  registration  of  the  vehicle  is  recorded. (9) In  this  section “certificate  of  registration”  includes  a  certificate  of  registration  renewed under  the  provisions  of  this  Act. Corresponding  Law. – Section  55  corresponds  to  section  34  of  the  Motor  Vehicles  Act, 1939.
Objects  and  Reasons. – Clause  55  contains  provisions  for  the  cancellation  of  the  certificate  of  registration  by  the  registering  authorities  where  the  vehicle  has  been  destroyed  or  has  been  rendered  permanently  incapable  of  use  or  has  been  lost  and  not  recovered  or  is  otherwise  not  traceable  or  its  use  will  constitute  a  danger  to  public  safety.  It  also  provides  that  the  registering  authorities  may  cancel  the  certificate  of  registration  if  the  registering  authority  is  satisfied  that engine  number  and  chassis  number  noted  in  the  certificate  of  registration  differs  from  that  found  in  the  vehicle,  or  that  the  registration  has  been  obtained  by  misrepresentation  or  fraud.


Sunday, March 27, 2011

Customer should know … in event of major car loss


Insurance claim process should be known to the INDIAN customer in the event of claim to enable him to get his legitimate insurance claim out of an insurance claim and more so in the event the vehicle having suffered major loss, wherein Insurers and Surveyors will be negotiating for settlement of claim and informing you of insurance related terms as Depreciation, Total Loss, Constructive total loss , IDV, Net of salvage, Cash loss settlement and salvage value .

In India the car losses, for major losses if considered on total loss basis by insurers market value of the vehicle is not considered ,but the concept of IDV ( Insured Declared value) is taken and the customer in event of total loss can claim full insured value of his car as per IDV. The criteria of consideration of claim on total loss basis is subject to condition that if the vehicle has suffered loss more than 75% of the insurers liability on repairs basis based on IDV of vehicle. In case the vehicle is Total Loss then the insured is paid the full IDV and he has to get the vehicle salvage shifted to the insurers desired premises and has to transfer the ownership rites in favour of the insurers or has to get the registration of the vehicle cancelled from the registration authority ( RTO) as directed by the insurers.


Constructive Total Loss is another type of settlement, when the insurers settle your claim as Total loss. This mode is generally adopted when the IDV of the vehicle is less than its market value and liability of insurers on total loss basis is in interest of insurers. In such cases, if IDV less salvage value is lower than the repair liability such mode may be adopted.


Cash Loss Basis is another way of settlement of claim and in such cases the insured is paid repairs cost less some percentage as agreed by the insured and insurers mutually and is generally about 30% . In this mode of settlement the settlement is done prior to vehicle being repaired and the insured after settlement may get the same repaired in any manner and at any workshop and does not have to prove that that the vehicle is repaired and does not have to submit the bills of repairs. Such mode is opted mostly in case where insured claims as per authorised workshop estimates and after settlement on cash loss basis may get the repairs carried out at some local workshops with used parts and depends on the financial status of the insured.


Cash Loss Basis Net of Salvage.. in this type of settlement in event of major loss the settlement is on total loss basis and salvage is also retained by the insured. Thereby the insurers pay the customer the IDV value less salvage value of the vehicle and any other additional deductions as per the policy. Thereafter the insured is free to either repair or dispose off the vehicle and does not have to submit the bills of repairs or transfer the ownership rites to the insurers.

IN INDIA at present many cases are mostly being settled on cash loss net of salvage basis and mostly by the private insurers.


BUT

There are some more factors operative in settlement on cash loss net of salvage basis. With their own pros and cons.
On very few occasions that the insured may agree for settlement on cash loss net of salvage basis in its true spirit. Thereby he after settlement will retain the salvage himself and will get the vehicle repaired by him-self from some unauthorised workshop and thereby make the said mode of settlement beneficial for him as otherwise if he get the vehicle repaired from authorised workshop then the said mode will definitely be a loss making settlement for him.
However on most of the occasion the said mode of settlement is adopted in reports of insurance companies and is consented by the insureds , In practice in such cases the biggest hurdle is that the customer/ insured is not interested in retaining the salvage and either the insurers or the surveyors facilitate to arrange for the salvage buyers and thereby the said hurdle is overcome.

CAUTION ....  As per section 55 of MV Act, for all vehicles which are destroyed or rendered incapable of use the RCs need to be cancelled. 
The said duty is of the owner of the vehicle. If owner retains the vehicle and get it repaired on his own then there is no problem, but when he sells the vehicle salvage then he should take preventive measures against misuse of the salvage by buyer. The customer should demand from the insurers / surveyor regarding certification confirming the salvage value deducted by them and also importantly confirming that the value so deducted was considered for disposal with or without documents. The same will have bearing on the future sale of the vehicle. If they deduct the value without the documents then one should get the RC cancelled and dispose the wreck and should not get it repaired. If the value quoted is with the documents then customer may sell the salvage with documents if he so desires after taking some preventive measures as discussed in a related article in this blog.


Many a customer of private insurers do sometimes claim that they were paid the reduced IDV which is violation of the insurance policy in INDIA. They complain that collective value paid to them for the salvage and insurers is less than the IDV and they had given the consent for the same for settlement purpose. This complain is mostly reported against private insurers in INDIA but the same is not the true representation of all the cases.

CASH LOSS NET OF SALVAGE BASIS is also a very good way of settlement of claims and is mostly helpful to the customers as explained in major loss cases.

In event of major loss if the liability of insurers is less than 75%of IDV then the option available is for repairs basis, but there is mostly a vast difference in market value and the IDV as IDV is a scaled value system for all type of vehicles. In many cases it is not adviseable as said repairs will not be economical for the insured as even after the repairs the market value may not be worth to bear the burden of depreciations etc. Also in many cases after the accident the insured does not want to retain the vehicle for phycologial reasons in event of major loss. In such cases he may propose to insurers that his claim though not falling under Total loss be settled on cash loss net of salvage basis on reduced IDV value thereby making the settlement for insurers in their interest and changing their decision from repairs basis to to cash loss net of salvage basis.


EXAMPLE

IDV is Rs 3,00,000.00
Repairs liability Rs 1,50,000.00
Depriciation on Repairs basis to be born by insured Say Rs 40,000.00
Salvage value Rs 1,00,000.00 on Total loss basis.
In above case the insurers will insist on repairs basis and say if the market value of the vehicle after repairs will be Rs 2,50,000.00 then the customer should try to get his vehicle settled on reduced IDV basis as consented mode of settlement.
Here if the insured proposes to the insurers that he is ready to settle his claim on cash loss basis for Rs 2,50,000.00 or say Rs 2,40,000.00 and the salvage be arranged for disposal ( Provide facilitation for salvage disposal) this will make the liability of insurers on cash loss net of salvage basis as Rs 1,50,000.00 or say Rs 1,40,000.00 respectively for the above values. This will now be in interest of the insurers and they can not ignore the said proposal of the insured. Here the insured is also not at loss as he assumes that he had to bear depreciation part only.

Cash loss net of salvage basis on reduced IDV basis on consented basis is very effective way of settlement of losses, Any forced settlement by this system  on the customer should be avoided and customer should be educated about this mode of settlement also and if he proposes on his own will for the said mode then only this mode should be adopted.

More to come in forthcoming posts……